I'll agree that it is better to vote for someone at random and hope to get a koopaling, and because no one had any way of knowing John was Mario, I think it's a fair assumption that those who did happen to vote for him are not more suspicious because of it.
There is however one piece of information for failed to take into account. One person was killed by the koopa's overnight, and by what we can only assume was bad luck on our part, we lost Peach as well. And who had motive to kill this person? Who openly disagreed with one of their posts? Jill did, making her the prime suspect in the murder of the princess.
That logic is flawed. A mafia member wouldn't be that obvious. Jill wasn't wrong either. A post that promotes anti-talking is anti-town. Therefore the doctor (JM) was in fact acting anti-town. I'm pretty sure they never played that game before so that's fine, but I doubt if Jill was mafia she would be so obvious to kill someone that she openly disagreed with. Though I wouldn't even call it that. Plus they never even voted for Jill after like they said they would. So it's not like they were gunning for her.
Last Edit: Apr 20, 2014 15:46:23 GMT -3.5 by OKtomcat: Removed quoted vote to avoid confusion during vote counting. Also fixed quote.
Just a reminder that we have 5 votes laid down so far for this day - Tricodin has 2, Jill has 3. That's less than half of the remaining townsfolk! Let's see some voting, people! If you don't take part in the voting process, the terro- I mean, Koopalings win!
Post by redbeard on Apr 21, 2014 17:41:22 GMT -3.5
On the one hand, there are now more empowered Koopalings than empowered Toads. On the other hand, there are more Toads. So firing in the dark means that we're more likely to shoot ourselves in the foot, but the Koopas will hurt more if we get one of them. I don't like choosing between two just because they're the only ones chosen so far. Though given the choice, I'd side with Newfie Steve's decision because he makes cookies and therefore has wisdom. I'm gonna Vote: OkTomcat because he's professing his innocence a little heavily. Granted, he could just be nervous, but I'm trusting my instincts here. And doing barrel rolls. And eating barrel-shaped rolls. Om nom nom...